What to buy first
A single tub of bath soak, not a bundle. Use it six times and you will know whether a soak is a habit you keep or a thing you bought once because a website suggested it. If it sticks, the multi-packs lower the cost per bath; if it does not, you are out one tub rather than five.
What this section will not tell you
What a magnesium soak does to a trained muscle. That is a claim about your body, and we have nothing to put behind it, so we do not make it. What we can compare is checkable: the published ingredient list, the size of the tub, the maker's own directions for how much to use, and what that works out to per bath. If a page tells you a bath salt fixes soreness, ask what it is citing.
How this category divides
Bath soaks are mostly one formula in several scents. A mineral base — commonly magnesium chloride flakes with Dead Sea minerals — carries one or two essential oils, or none at all in a fragrance-free version. Because the base is shared, the honest decision is scent and skin suitability rather than performance, and anyone claiming a meaningful difference between a eucalyptus tub and a lavender one is selling.
What decides the price
How far the tub goes, which is a function of how you use it rather than what you paid. A full bath takes one to two cups; a foot soak takes half to one. The same 3 lb tub is therefore three baths or a dozen foot soaks, and the cost per use swings by a factor of four on that choice alone — a bigger difference than anything separating the brands.
What people get wrong
Treating the bath as the recovery plan. How you feel on Thursday is decided by how hard you went on Tuesday, whether you slept and whether you ate. If soreness is affecting your training, the fix is in the progression you are following, not in the bathroom. A soak is a pleasant end to a session and should be bought as one.